Let's get started on your personalized insurance quote.

Working with The Overmyer Insurance Agency is easy.  We make purchasing your auto, homeowners, and business insurance simple.  Whether you buy your insurance policy online, over the phone, or in person, you will always have a dedicated insurance agent by your side.

We understand your time is valuable, and we work with you on your schedule.  Call or click today to get started on finding the right insurance company and coverage for your unique needs.


What type of insurance coverage can we help you customize and quote?

Insurance protecting family health live, house and car concept. Cut elements from paper th

Personal Auto, Homeowners, and Umbrella Insurance

Save your time and money. We quote your policies with the multiple companies we represent and bundle your auto and homeowners insurance coverage. We make finding the right insurance company and coverage simple.

Cafe Counter

Commercial & Small Business Insurance

Protect the business you built. Start a business insurance quote or coverage review with our business insurance experts. We make navigating your insurance needs simple so you can go and do what you do best, running your business.