top of page

About Us

We are real independent insurance agents, not bots or AI.

Agents, Not Bots is the heart of the Overmyer Insurance Agency, LLC. We pride ourselves in providing you with access to a dedicated agent and advisor that keeps your best interest and protection in mind.


Working with an independent insurance agent is a different experience than using a direct or online insurance company. We are your insurance advocate and advisor, coverage knowledge base, and have the real-life insights and expertise to customize your insurance policies to provide superior asset protection that fits your life and budget.  


As an independent insurance agency the Overmyer Insurance Agency is not tied down to one single insurance company, we work with many different insurance companies to find the best fit for you. The Overmyer Insurance Agency is locally based in Cranford, New Jersey, and is always customer service-focused. No need to be on hold or deal with the frustration of contacting an unknown customer service call center in the event of a claim or policy question.


Whether you have to report a claim, would like an insurance policy quote, or simply have a question, we are here for you.

About Adam Overmyer:

Adam Overmyer has over 20 years of insurance industry experience and has been a licensed insurance agent since 2000. After working in the customer service department at a large insurance company for over 2 years, Adam became an independent agent in 2002.  Both opportunities have provided Adam with extensive insurance industry, coverage, and customer service knowledge.  

Overmyer Insurance Agency was started to give clients an alternative to online-based insurance options and to provide direct access with a personal insurance advisor. With 22 years of insurance industry customer service history, Adam has worked with everything from individual small claims to catastrophic storms affecting a large number of clients.  Adam has always been dedicated to providing the best customer service, providing adequate coverage options, and be an advocate for clients.  

Overmyer Insurance Agency, Cranford NJ 07016


Excellent customer service is what OIA is known for. We are very appreciative of what our clients have to say about their insurance experiences.

"Adam at Overmyer has been fantastic - super friendly and helpful. We reviewed and revamped our insurance policy and it’s providing me with more coverage for the same price. The customer service is above and beyond. I love that I can contact them if there is an issue and don’t ever have to deal with the insurance companies directly or ever wait on hold. So much easier! Highly recommend."

-Laurie D.

Start A Quote Today

Click below for a better and more personalized insurance experience without the hassle.

bottom of page