top of page
Auto Insurance Cranford NJ 07016 - Overmyer Insurance Agency

Saving money on your auto insurance is just the start.

Buying auto insurance should not be complicated or time-consuming, optimize your insurance experience with dedicated local independent insurance experts.

This Is Insurance The OIA Way.

Or, skip ahead and call us at 908-476-8685

The Overmyer Insurance Agency specializes in auto, home, umbrella, business, and commercial insurance coverage in the New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania regions. 
No matter where you are, we are there for you.

Scotch Plains NJ 07076 Auto Insurance

Scotch Plains NJ Auto Insurance Designed For You

Buying the right auto insurance can be time consuming and frustrating.   
We solve this by partnering with many insurance companies to make finding and customizing the right insurance coverage and cost easy.  

Insurance For People, Made By People

Once you start an auto insurance policy with the Overmyer Insurance Agency, our job is just beginning.

We are here for you if you have any questions, need to report a claim, or need assistance.  No random call centers or inexperienced customer service reps here!


Excellent customer service is what OIA is known for. We are very appreciative of what our clients have to say about their insurance experiences.

"Adam at Overmyer has been fantastic - super friendly and helpful. We reviewed and revamped our insurance policy and it’s providing me with more coverage for the same price. The customer service is above and beyond. I love that I can contact them if there is an issue and don’t ever have to deal with the insurance companies directly or ever wait on hold. So much easier! Highly recommend."

-Laurie D.

Finding The Right Insurance Coverage Doesn't Need To Be Complicated and Time-Consuming.

Our streamlined process provides you with a frictionless insurance experience:


Give a little info, get a lot of insight

Start entering the information about your business or home and auto insurance needs, and we will take care of the rest.


We analyze your needs 

We start by pricing and quoting your policies with the multiple insurance companies we represent, then we fine-tune the coverage to meet your needs and budget.


Insurance designed for you in mind

Together we match you with the best insurance company, pricing, and coverage to fit your needs.


Real-Time Consulting

We are here for you.  As your dedicated personal insurance advisors, we are just a call or click away for questions, claim assistance, policy changes, or coverage reviews.

Amazing Scotch Plains NJ auto insurance is not the only insurance coverage we can help you with:

Personal Insurance:

  • Homeowners Insurance 

  • Secondary and Seasonal Homes

  • Coastal Homeowners Insurance

  • Landlord and Rental Property

  • Short Term Rental Insurance (Airbnb)

  • Historic & High-Value Home Insurance

  • Personal Excess Liability/Umbrella Insurance

  • Fine Art, Valuable Collection, and Jewelry Insurance

  • Flood Insurance

  • Classic Car Insurance

  • Boat/Yacht Insurance

  • RV & Recreational Vehicle Insurance

Business Insurance:

Start A Quote Today

Click below for a better and more personalized insurance experience without the hassle.
bottom of page